There are currently four expansion sets for Flying Frog Productions' boardgame, A Touch Of Evil, and I'm going to take a brief look at them here.
Something Wicked is the first of the two big expansion sets and it contains quite a lot - 1 Full Colour Rulebook, 1 Expansion Game Board, 4 Unique 28mm Scale Hero Figures, 20 Card Monastery Deck, 20 Card Forgotten Island Deck, 20 Card The Inn Deck, 12 Monastery Item Cards, 4 Abandoned Keep Cards, 4 Manor Cards, 4 Olde Woods Cards, 4 Windmill Cards, 9 Lair Cards, 8 Event Cards, 12 Mystery Cards, 1 Town Item Card, 4 Curse of Stone Cards, 2 Possessed/ Crimson Hand Cards, 4 Large Hero Character Record Sheets, 4 Large Villain Record Sheets, 4 Extra Large Villain Minion Chart Cards, 1 Large Reference Card for Terrain Effects and 3 Full Colour Sheets of Die-Cut Counters. This expansion set adds the Echo Lake game board, which can be added to the right of the Shadowbrook board, doubling the size of the total game board. Echo Lake adds three new Corner Locations (Forgotten Island, The Inn and The Monastery), as well as new Dangerous Locations and paths that may be travelled.I'll describe the four new Heroes in greater detail next time, along with photos of them. The four new Villains are the Banshee, the Gargoyle, the Bog Fiend and the Unspeakable Horror (a Cthulhu-type monster). There are a few new rules added to the game, most of which are optional. However, some of these optional rules are highly recommended, e.g. Too Many Secrets, Exchanging Items and Allies in the Competitive Game and using the Advanced Cooperative Mystery Phase Chart (for this you roll 2d6 and consult the chart instead of rolling 1d6 and having fewer options on the original chart). For me, the best new rules of all were the solo play rules. These are split into using a single Hero or a team of Heroes (2 to 3 being the recommended number). As a solo player, these new rules made this expansion set a must have purchase. If you're a solo player you'll need this set.
The Coast is the second big expansion set and it contains the following - 1 Full Colour Rulebook, 1 Expansion Game Board, 4 Unique 28mm Scale Hero Figures, 20 Card Lighthouse Deck, 20 Card Shipwreck Deck, 20 Card Smuggler's Cove Deck, 12 Coastal Town Items, 12 Tidewater Village Encounter Cards, 7 Hauntings Cards, 8 Secrets Cards, 3 Tidewater Town Elders Cards, 4 Abandoned Keep Cards, 4 Manor Cards, 4 Olde Woods Cards, 4 Windmill Cards, 12 Lair Cards, 12 Event Cards, 22 Mystery Cards, 1 Town Item Card, 1 Drowned Dead Card, 4 Large Hero Character Record Sheets, 4 Large Villain Record Sheets, 4 Extra Large Villain Minion Charts, 1 Large Reference Card of Kraken/Haunted, 1 Extra Large Reference Card for Lost Ship and 2 Full Colour Sheets of Die-Cut Counters. This expansion features a coastline to explore. It may be added to the Shadowbrook board and sits neatly to the right of it, doubling the size of the total game board. If you also have the Echo Lake board from the Something Wicked expansion, the three boards may be used together, lining up the roads from Shadowbrook, through Echo Lake to the Coast. The Coast board adds three new Corner Locations (the Lighthouse, the Shipwreck and the Smuggler's Cove) as well as the town of Tidewater, new Dangerous Locations and a few new paths that may be travelled.
Once again, I'll describe the four new Heroes in greater detail next time, along with photos of them. The four new Villains are the Dreamweaver, the Ghost Ship, the Siren and the Sunken Seven Ghostly Horde. More new rules are introduced, all of which add to the flavour of the game. One notable feature of Tidewater is that it has its own group of Town Elders, albeit fewer in number than in Shadowbrook - three instead of six. Just like their counterparts from inland these three characters have their own Secrets and they may help or hinder the Heroes in their quest to vanquish evil. I have yet to play this expansion set but I am immensely looking forward to trying it out as I have read nothing but good reviews of it. Indeed, I have heard some say it is the best expansion set for the game. With the inclusion of ghosts and undead pirates I say, what's not to like about it? I'll play a few games using The Coast with the original set and omit the Something Wicked board but what I'm really looking forward to is playing some truly epic games using all three sets.
Hero Pack One is a much smaller expansion set and it contains the following - 1 Full Colour Rules Booklet, 4 Unique 28mm Scale Hero Figures, 4 Large Hero Character Record Sheets, 6 Event Cards, 1 Abandoned Keep Card, 1 Manor Card, 1 Olde Woods Card, 1 Windmill Card and 1 Large Villain Record Sheet. Note that the new Necromancer Villain uses the Vampire Minion Chart from the A Touch Of Evil base game.
The Hero Pack One expansion introduces four new monster hunting Heroes - Adrianna Quetado the Foreign Traveller, Harlow Morgan the Inventor, Lucy Hanbrook and the Scarlet Shadow. I reviewed these figures last time. Also included are 10 powerful Event and Location Cards, which are meant to be shuffled into their respective decks.
The new villain is the Necromancer. With total control of the Walking Dead, the Necromancer strangles the streets of Shadowbrook with an endless horde of zombie minions and an unquenchable thirst for destruction.
I found it slightly misleading that the back cover of the game box prominently features a picture of Valeria the Eternal, a Hero from Something Wicked. For sure, you can mix and match the Heroes from all the sets but if you bought this set before Something Wicked, there is a good chance you might ask, who is that woman in the red dress and why isn't she in this set? Yes, it is only a minor criticism but it did make me wonder.
This is not a bad expansion set but it is not quite as essential as the two big expansion sets described above. Still, it does offer four more Heroes and a new villain to conquer, thus giving you more options and variety.
Hero Pack Two is very similar to Hero Pack One and contains the following - 1 Full Colour Rules Booklet, 4 Unique 28mm Scale Hero Figures, 4 Large Hero Character Record Sheets, 3 Event Cards, 3 Mystery Cards, 1 Abandoned Keep Card, 1 Manor Card, 1 Olde Woods Card, 1 Windmill Card, 1 Large Villain Record Sheet and 1 Extra Large Villain Minion Chart.
Hero Pack Two introduces four exciting new Heroes - Frederic Leon the Foreign Diplomat, Jack Fellows the Privateer, Abigail Sturn the Student of the Occult and Sara Essex the Bright Witch. I'll review these and the new Heroes from Something Wicked and The Coast in my next post. The 10 new cards should be shuffled into their respective decks.
The new Villain is the Reaper, a master of death and decay who brings withering despair to all that it touches. Casting its Dark Mark on the next unlucky victim, the Reaper harvests souls to feed its fetid hunger.
I don't have a lot to say about this expansion set. As with Hero Pack One, it comes with four new Heroes, a new Villain and an extra 10 cards. If you're a completist like me, you'll want this set but I can hardly describe either of these two small expansion sets as essential purchases. They are useful to have but if it comes down to affordability I'd recommend giving them a miss and buy either or both of the big expansion sets if you don't already have them.
Amazon UK currently has the two big expansion sets in stock. Something Wicked retails for £28.30. The Coast is slightly cheaper at £27.75. Hero Pack One and Hero Pack Two cost me about £15.00 each when I ordered them from Amazon. They are currently out of stock but I've just checked to see if they are available on eBay and they are, with both being offered for a tad over £20.00 each.
Finally, please note that all four expansion sets require that you own the original base set.
Nice review(s) Bryan, especially sweet as this is one of my all time favourite games; I believe it will probably become a `classic` in another half decade or so, once it matures enough to become a `retro` game (have you ever noticed how it is that games only seem to reach classic status once they are no longer easily available to buy anywhere, haha).
ReplyDeleteI dunno, there is just something streamline and enthusiastically addictive about this little beauty (is it so little?). Maybe it`s the no nonsense theme... the game is blindingly clear what it is and almost nonchalantly proclaims "hey, I`m all about late 18th century macabre horror, with a touch of Poldark, Last of the Mohicans, and the Onedin Line thrown in for good measure and added atmosphere." Perhaps more to the point, it does this with a simplistic grace that almost defies the many expansions available to make this game `complete`... what I mean here I think is that, with the base game, two expansions, plus the additional hero sets, the game weighs in at 5 boxes worth of goodness; but at no point do the additional rules make the game unwieldy or over complex.
For me personally, because I feel the whole thing is more of an `experience`... or perhaps more aptly, a `themed experience` I actually think you probably DO need to go the completest route with this one, and get the game and all its expansions: simply to get the whole flavour in all its sheer unadulterated bliss, as one huge giant package (pretty much the same way I feel about a few other games like Descent, Journeys in the Dark, and Talisman).
Really enjoyed this review Bryan. Nice one mate.
Steve, we are definitely reading from the same page. Playing ATOE is an experience, and for me, a very enjoyable experience. The expansion sets greatly enhance that experience and I'm very happy to own all of them.
DeleteIt's funny that you mentioned "Poldark" as being a source of reference for the game. I have been watching the new series of "Poldark" on BBC1 purely because of my love of ATOE. I never watched the old series but the new series piqued my interest and although it has nothing to do with supernatural horror the similarities are there to be seen with the characters, costumes and setting.
Yes, it is true that a lot of games only reach classic status once they disappear from the shelves. It would be nice to think that ATOE will be regarded as a classic in the future. Many thanks for your kind words.
Great stuff Bryan. Really really tempting I must say... And I can now easily see myself staggering back from Salute with this game under my arm. Either that or upon returning from the show make full use of my Amazon Prime account ;-)
ReplyDeleteEither way it sounds like a win-win situation to me, Simon. You might be even more tempted after I show you the second set of Heroes.
DeleteI always worry when a string of releases occur. It makes me think that not enough care and attention has gone into each one. It also makes me realise that you cannot get comfortable with one game before the "New and Improve" it. I hope this is not the case and that the game is not swamped with new stuff just to make money. You seem to indicate that it is not and I do hope you are right.
ReplyDeleteNice review though despite my scepticism
Let me reassure you that Flying Frog are not flooding the market with expansion sets for this game. ATOE came out in 2008. In 2009, Something Wicked and Hero Pack 1 were released. In 2012 The Coast and Hero Pack 2 were released. There's nothing wrong in having a dose of scepticism but in this case it is unfounded.
DeleteDang, but this sounds interesting! I'm surprised that I haven't heard of "A Touch of Evil" before this series of posts, but now I'm trying hard to resist.
ReplyDeleteAs you can see from my reply to Clint the game and its expansions have been out a long time now. I'm totally smitten with the game, Hugh.
Delete